Full Catalog

Everything We Bake

Every size, price, and flavor in one place — handy for browsing or printing. To order online with add-to-cart, visit the menu.

Vintage & Designer Cakes

Raspberry Vintage Cake

Mini — serves 4 — $45.00 · 6 inch — serves 6–8 — $70.00 · 8 inch — serves 10–15 — $90.00

Flavors: Silky Vanilla, Lotus Biscoff Bliss, Nutella Dream, Chocolate Fudge Obsession, Oreo Cookies and Cream, Strawberry Chantilly, Coffee Velvet, Classic Tiramisu, Pistachio, Pink Raspberry / Strawberry, Lemon Blueberry, Berries with Chocolate

Frosting: Buttercream, Cream Cheese

Larger sizes available on request — reach out through our custom cake form.

English Bloom Cake

Mini — serves 4 — $45.00 · 6 inch — serves 6–8 — $70.00 · 8 inch — serves 10–15 — $90.00

Frosting: Buttercream, Cream Cheese

Larger sizes available on request — reach out through our custom cake form.

Garden Vintage Cake

Mini — serves 4 — $45.00 · 6 inch — serves 6–8 — $70.00 · 8 inch — serves 10–15 — $90.00

Frosting: Buttercream, Cream Cheese

Larger sizes available on request — reach out through our custom cake form.

Mini Celebration Cakes

Single mini cake — $45.00

Frosting: Buttercream, Cream Cheese

Gender Reveal Cake

Mini — serves 4 — $45.00 · 6 inch — serves 6–8 — $75.00 · 8 inch — serves 8–10 — $90.00

Frosting: Buttercream, Cream Cheese

Let us know the reveal color (pink or blue) — or ask us to keep it a surprise — in your order notes.

Sunflower Cake

Mini — serves 4 — $45.00 · 6 inch — serves 6–8 — $70.00 · 8 inch — serves 10–15 — $90.00

Frosting: Buttercream, Cream Cheese

Larger sizes available on request — reach out through our custom cake form.

Flamingo Lily Cake

Standard size — serves 6 — $65.00

Frosting: Buttercream, Cream Cheese

Larger sizes available on request — reach out through our custom cake form.

English Daisy Fruit Cake

Mini — serves 4 — $45.00 · 6 inch — serves 6–8 — $70.00 · 8 inch — serves 10–15 — $90.00

Flavors: Strawberry, Blueberries, Raspberries, Mangoes, Dragon Fruit, Kiwi, Mix of Fruits (+$10)

Frosting: Buttercream, Cream Cheese

Larger sizes available on request — reach out through our custom cake form.

Rich Burgundy Cake

Mini — serves 4 — $45.00 · 6 inch — serves 6–8 — $70.00 · 8 inch — serves 10–15 — $90.00

Frosting: Buttercream, Cream Cheese

Larger sizes available on request — reach out through our custom cake form.

Fruit Tower

Standard size — serves 8 — $40.00

Fruit selection is subject to seasonal availability.

Lemon Blueberry Cake

6 inch — serves 6–8 — $70.00 · 8 inch — serves 10–12 — $90.00

Frosting: Buttercream, Cream Cheese

Larger sizes available on request — reach out through our custom cake form.

Garden Vintage Cake (for Boy)

Mini — serves 4 — $45.00 · 6 inch — serves 6–8 — $70.00 · 8 inch — serves 10–15 — $90.00

Frosting: Buttercream, Cream Cheese

Larger sizes available on request — reach out through our custom cake form.

Cheesecakes

Signature Basque Cheesecake

Standard size — serves 8–10 — $55.00

Flavors: Dark Chocolate Raspberry, Oreo and Nutella, Lotus Biscoff, Crunchy Pecan, Caramel & Dark Chocolate, Ferrero Rocher (+$5)

New York Style Cheesecake

Standard size — serves 8–10 — $65.00

Flavors: Nutella Topped, Oreo Crusted, Biscoff Crusted, Latte / Coffee, Strawberry, Raspberry, Blueberry, Blackberry

Cheesecake Dessert Cups

Set of 6 — $35.00 · Set of 10 — $45.00

Flavors: Strawberry Cheesecake Parfait, Nutella Mousse, Oreo Cookies and Cream Pudding, Classic Tiramisu, Lotus Biscoff Mousse, Reese's Peanut Butter Cup, Pistachio Parfait, Coffee Velvet, Assortment (different flavours in a box) (+$5 USD)

Mini Cheesecakes

Single mini cheesecake — $30.00

Flavors: Basque Style, New York Style

Biscoff Crusted Cheesecake

Mini — serves 4 — $35.00 · Standard size — serves 8–10 — $65.00

Cupcakes

Cheesecake Cupcakes

Set of 8 — $35.00 · Set of 12 — $45.00

Flavors: Nutella Oreo Cheesecake, Oreo Cheesecake, Biscoff Cheesecake, Strawberry Parfait, Classic Tiramisu, Assortment (different flavours in a box) (+$5 USD)

Cupcakes

Set of 4 — $20.00 · Set of 6 — $28.00 · Set of 12 — $45.00

Flavors: Silky Vanilla, Chocolate Fudge, Nutella, Tiramisu, Oreo Cookies and Cream, Lotus Biscoff, Coffee, Pistachio, Lemon, Blueberry, Strawberry Chantilly, Raspberry

Cookies & Brownies

Signature Cookies

Set of 6 — $30.00 · Set of 12 — $40.00

Flavors: Center Filled Lotus Biscoff, Nutella Filled, Dark Chocolate Chip

Velvety Brownies

Set of 9 — $30.00 · Bucket of mini brownies (preferred toppings) — $30.00

Flavors: Tiramisu, Nutella, Biscoff, Oreo, Pecans, Pistachio & Cashew, Coffee

Choose your preferred toppings — let us know in your order notes.

Gift Baskets

Gift Basket

Standard basket — $125.00

Any fruit shown may be substituted with your preferred fruit, subject to seasonal availability.

Pickups in Fairlawn — Delivering all Northeast Ohio

We recommend ordering at least 3–7 days in advance. Custom cakes require a 50% deposit to confirm.

buttermeupbakeryohio@gmail.com · +1 (330) 814-9007